Congratulations to the 2017 high school football Msgr. Martin Association All-Star Team:
| Offense | ||
| QB | Casey Kelly | St. Joes |
| RB | Jaden Lofton | St. Joes |
| RB | Kenyatta Huston | Canisius |
| OL | Brad Currell | Canisius |
| OL | Cameron Dabill | St. Joes |
| OL | Tyler Doty | St. Joes |
| OL | Jadd Dolegala | St. Francis |
| OL | Stephen Boyd | Cardinal O'Hara |
| WR | Michah Brown | St. Joes |
| WR | Paul Woods | Canisius |
| WR | Dominik Thomas | St. Francis |
| Kicker | Reilly Miller | St. Francis |
| Utility | Jordan Hill | Timon |
| Defense | ||
| DL | Will McGennis | Canisius |
| DL | Connor Dean | Timon |
| DL | Nick DeLuca | Canisius |
| DL | Michon Dudley | Cardinal O'Hara |
| LB | Joe Jamison | Canisius |
| LB | Joel Nicholas | Canisius |
| LB | Remir Velazquez | Cardinal O'Hara |
| LB | Riley Wood | St. Joes |
| DB | Keenan Ollison | Canisius |
| DB | Anthony McCarley | St. Joes |
| DB | Nasir Benton | Cardinal O'Hara |
| DB | Melique Straker | St. Francis |
| Punter | Cullen Tonge | Timon |