Breaking News
More () »

Jury finds man guilty of setting ex-girlfriend on fire

Jonathon White, 28, was found guilty of attempted murder after he set his ex-girlfriend, Jessica Cameron, on fire outside a Tim Hortons last December.

BUFFALO, N.Y. — The jury has found a man accused of setting his ex-girlfriend on fire guilty. 

Jonathon White, 28, was found guilty of attempted murder and assault. He set his ex-girlfriend, Jessica Cameron, on fire outside a Tim Hortons last December in the City of Tonawanda.

"I'm disappointed, but this is the way the system works, and we'll be filing an appeal the day that he's sentenced on January third," says defense attorney Joseph Terranova.

"I told her that if she ever needs any help for the rest of her life, she knows that we're here to help her. And, I'm also equally committed to helping the defendant. I'm equally committed to helping him spend the next 25 years in jail," said Erie County District Attorney John Flynn.

Late Friday, the jury asked the judge for clarification on the definitions of intent and the attempted murder charge. 

"When they came back and asked for additional instructions on the attempted murder, it seemed as if that was perhaps a sticking point and at that time, it could have gone either way. They could have decided, yeah, based on those legal instructions, we don't have that. We don't see that, and so, in my opinion, when they made that request, I thought it could have gone either way," said Terranova.

But within minutes, the jury delivered its guilty verdicts.

"His intent of doing harm, thinking about that, executing on that harm by dumping it over her head and lighting her on fire, rises to a level of evilness that screams for 25 years here. It's just ridiculous to think of anything less than 25 years here," says Flynn.

Shortly after jurors started deliberating, they sent three notes to the judge. One note asked to see the video surveillance footage, another note asked for cross-examination and redirect testimony of White, and the third note asked to see images of the scene showing the backpack. State Supreme Court Judge Mark Montour sent a note back asking the jury to clarify what specific transcripts, images, and video they would like to see while they continued to deliberate. 

Credit: Pool Camera
Jessica Cameron testifies in court

During his closing arguments, Defense Attorney Joseph Terranova addressed the jury saying, "My job is to point out to you what those reasonable doubts may be."

Terranova points out the jury did not hear from the forensic chemist who originally tested the evidence for ignitable fluids, saying a substitute gave testimony instead after reviewing the initial report. 

Kaitlin Drollette is the forensic chemist for the Erie County Central Police Services. Drollette was not the chemist who originally tested the items. She reviewed the report from another chemist who was not able to appear in court to testify because she recently gave birth and was on maternity leave.

Credit: Pool Camera
Defense attorney Joseph Terranova with his opening statements during the jury trial of Jonathon White,

Terranova says the gas cans found at White's residence were not fingerprinted, despite being used by prosecution to link White to the crime. "They cannot be linked to my client other than they were out in the open at his residence," said Terranova.

Terranova also said a piece of "key evidence," the white BIC lighter, was never produced for the jury, and that police testified during the trial that the lighter had not been tested to see if it worked. 

Terranova told the jury that they are not here (in court) to decide if Jessica Cameron was horribly burned and disfigured, but whether it was his client's intent to kill her by pouring gasoline on her and setting her on fire.  

"Your job as jurors is to decide this case on the facts and the law without sympathy," Terranova said to the jury before concluding.

In the prosecution's closing arguments, the jury heard the fire described as an "ambush", not an accident.

Credit: pool camera
Assistant DA Ryan D. Haggerty, pointing to defendant, during the people's closing arguments.

The prosecution also pointed to body cam video where Cameron said White poured gasoline on her and lit her on fire.

“Everything you need to know to find this defendant guilty is in those 20 seconds,” the prosecution said to the jury.

The prosecution also told jurors that White's injuries are not consistent with someone claiming to be burned to the degree he claims.

“Regret, even if genuine, does not negate intent,” argued the prosecution.

During the trial, jurors heard from police officers who arrived on scene after the 911 call was made, as well as investigators, hospital officials and co-workers of Cameron.

RELATED: Woman set on fire testifies against ex-boyfriend

Cameron herself took the witness stand on Thursday and provided emotional testimony of her relationship with White and the events of that day in December. 

Cameron testified she knew something was not right when she noticed an apple juice container by the dumpster. When she asked White if he was going to hurt her, she said he responded "yes."

She said White took that apple juice container, opened it and poured the entire contents over her head. She said she could smell gasoline as the liquid was poured over her head. 

Cameron said she was initially in shock and that once she turned around, she was on fire. The first thing she noticed was the heat and burning pain everywhere. 

Cameron sustained extensive burns to her face, head, and hands. She spent several months in the burn unit at ECMC and is still recovering from her physical injuries.

White claimed he did not intend to set Cameron on fire, he said he intended to set himself on fire. 

White told jurors that at one point, while he was asking questions, he pulled the bottle with gasoline in it out of his pocket and began pouring the gas on himself. He claimed he and Cameron struggled with the bottle as she tried to take it out of his hand. At the same time, he said, he pulled his lighter out of his pocket. White says he felt gasoline go down his back. 

White says at some point, the lighter went off and sparked.  His attorney asked, "But your hair wasn't damaged?" White responded by saying, "my head was literally on fire."

White faces 25 years in prison when he's sentenced in January.

RELATED: Jonathon White trial: Day 2

RELATED: Trial begins for WNY man accused of setting girlfriend on fire

Paid Advertisement

Before You Leave, Check This Out