Bill Moore, Lackawanna (3)
John Faller, Sweet Home (2)
Eric Jantzi, North Tonawanda (2)
Gene Tundo, Orchard Park (2)
Notes:
- Coaches from Catholic schools have been selected coach of the year four times.
- There have been multiple winners in five years
- 15 schools have had their head football coach selection as the NFL/ Buffalo Bills Coach of the Year