| First Team: |
| QB - Randall Secky, Maple Grove |
| RB - Wade Turner, Lackawanna |
| RB - Sandro DeAngelis, St. Joe's |
| RB - Joe Kusmierski, Tonawanda |
| WR - Chris Lumley, Niagara Wheatfield |
| WR - Josh Liddell, Maple Grove |
| TE - Chad Bartoszek, Salamanca |
| OL - Justin King, Hamburg |
| OL - Mark Campanella, St. Joe's |
| OL - Cleyton Smith, Niagara Wheatfield |
| OL - Russ Fenton, West Seneca West |
| K - Dallas Pelz, St. Francis |
| UT- Joe West, Lackawanna |
| DL - Josh Thomas, Orchard Park |
| DL - Nate Milne, Jamestown |
| DL - Doug Harding, Lackawanna |
| DL - Keith O'Neil, Sweet Home |
| LB - Kurt Miller, West Seneca West |
| LB - Joe Pannulio, Orchard Park |
| LB - Matt Zielinski, Clarence |
| DB - Aaron Sawyer, Orchard Park |
| DB - Jason Herman, Niagara Wheatfield |
| DB - Brad Greenfield, Grand Island |
| P - Geoff Gane, North Tonawanda |