| 1982-83, Kraig Kurzanski, Canisius - OL |
| 1983, Dennis Gilbert, St. Joes - DB |
| 1985, Jody Lomeo, St. Joe's - DB |
| 1955-57, Mike Fitzpatrick, Timon - RB/WR |
| 1956, Ray Gallagher, Baker - OL |
| 1963, Paul Tokasz, Ryan - RB |
| 1964, Jim Cavanaugh, St. Joe's - RB |
| 1965, Doug Hartmayer, Cardinal O'Hara - WR |
| 1963-1965, Paul Fitzpatrick, Timon - RB |
| 1968, Jeff Yeates, Cardinal O'Hara - L |
| 1977, Rich Coppolla, Neuman - DB |
| 1974, Mike Ervolina, Neuman - LB |
| 1971-73, Pete Coppolla, Neuman - DB |
| 1969-70, Paul Vosburgh, DeSales - OL/LB |
| 1979, Mark Jurszanski, Timon - RB |