| First Team Offense |
| QB - Casey Kacz, Sweet Home |
| RB - Brandon Murie, Iroquois |
| RB - Capone Smith, Lackawanna |
| RB - Jeff Tundo, Orchard Park |
| WR - Alex Neutz, Grand Island |
| WR - Joe Caporale, Maple Grove |
| OL - Steve Phillips, Sweet Home |
| OL - Boomer Brock - Iroquois |
| OL - Ryan Wilson, Sweet Home |
| OL - Jasen Carlson, Southwestern |
| K - Chris Secky, Maple Grove |
| U - Aaron Davis, North Tonawanda |
| First Team Defense |
| DL - Pat Wilson, Canisius |
| DL - Curtis Hairston, Cleveland Hill |
| DL - John Urschel, Canisius |
| LB - Brendan Nuessle, Orchard Park |
| LB - Deshanaro Morris, Sweet Home |
| LB - Tim Hersey, Kenmore West |
| LB - Trent Alls, Riverside |
| DB - Delano Fabor, St. Francis |
| DB - Luke Tasker, St. Francis |
| DB - Rhakeem Wiggins, Cleveland Hill |
| DB - Dwayne Bennett, Lackawanna |
| P - Kyle Hoppy, Orchard Park |