| The following players are Dick Gallagher's picks for Top Defenders in week 4: |
| Alec Dietsch, Clarence |
| Andy Welchff, Nichols |
| Anthony Castellini, St. Joe's |
| Bill Schiavitti, Lew-port |
| Brandon Reilly, West Seneca East |
| Brendan Buryta, North Tonawanda |
| Cody Oldres, Randolph |
| Connor Eddy, Orchard Park |
| Cortland Haines, Jamestown |
| Damon Harris, Timon/St. Jude |
| Dan Weaver, Pine Valley |
| Derek Johnson, Maple Grove |
| Drew Horton, East Aurora |
| Ed Gardo Berrios, South Park |
| Hayden Schonert, Lancaster |
| Jack Bargnesi, St. Joe's |
| Jackson Brown, Timon/St. Jude |
| Jake Haight, Barker |
| Jason Bunk, Alden |
| Jerry Halt, Kenmore West |
| John Clearly, Iroquois |
| John Czech, Jamestown |
| Jonah Tanner, Maple Grove |
| Josh White, Cleveland Hill |
| Ken Williams, Nichols |
| Kenny Dillenburg, Cheektowaga |
| Kyle Violanti, Hamburg |
| Marcus Hampton, Burgard |
| Matt Wetzel, Starpoint |
| Mike Geiger, Nichols |
| Nate Keith, St. Mary's |
| Nick King, Frontier |
| Nick Nocek, Fredonia |
| Peter Trathen, Southwestern |
| Robert Desiderio, St. Mary's |
| Rod Payne, St. Joe's |
| Roderick Marrow, Burgard |
| Ryan Richards, Canisius |
| Ryan Wayne, Williamsville East |
| Tyler Norcla, East Aurora |
| Zach Torain, Dunkirk |
|
Zach Walkowski, JFK
Jack Bargnesi, St. Joe's
Dan Ferguson, Westfield/Ripley
Matt Booth, Cattaraugus/Little Valley
|