| 1958 - Kevin Brinkworth, St. Joseph's |
| 1959 - Don Gilbert, Bennett |
| 1960 - Jim McNally, Kenmore West |
| 1961 - John Chiasera, North Tonawanda |
| 1962 - Jim Robie, Williamsville |
| 1963 - Rick Cassta, Tonawanda |
| 1964 - Gary Moeller, Lew-Port |
| 1965 - Paul Fitzpatrick, Timon |
| 1966 - Joe Ehrmann, Riverside |
| 1967 - Jim Krieg, Kenmore East |
| 1968 - Jeff Yeates, O'Hara |
| 1969 - Ed Carney, Timon |
| 1970 - Mickey Donovan, Walsh |
| 1971 - Ed Guindon, Lancaster |
| 1972 - Mark Murphy, Clarence |
| 1973 - Peter Coppola, Neumann |
| 1974 - Bill Hurley, St. Joseph's |
| 1975 - Craig Wolfley |
| 1976 - Jim Rath, Frontier |
| 1977 - Mike Wallace, Fredonia |
| 1978 - Chris Rehbaum, St. Joseph's |
| 1979 - Mike Leavell, St. Francis |
| 1980 - Jim Dombrowski, Williamsville South |
| 1981 - Shane Conlan, Frewsburg |
| 1982 - Joe Shannon, Williamsville South |
| 1983 - Daryl Johnston, Lew-Port |
| 1984 - Dan Mettica, Williamsville South |
| 1985 - Kevin Deakin, St. Joseph's |
| 1986 - Ray Braxton, Lackawanna |
| 1987 - Mark Anderson, Orchard Park |
| 1988 - Jim Snyder, Medina |
| 1989 - Kevin Mason, West Seneca East |
| 1990 - Randy Smith, Lockport |
| 1991 - Bob McDonnell, Grand Island |
| 1992 - Ted McDuffie, Grover Cleveland |
| 1993 - Warren Miles, Lackawanna |
| 1994 - David Hinson, Jamestown |
| 1995 - Malik Campbell, Turner/Carroll |
| 1996 - Frank Pavicich, Niagara Wheatfield |
| 1997 - Frank Pavicich, Niagara Wheatfield |
| 1998 - Sandra DeAngels, St. Joseph's |
| 1999 - Joe West, Lackawanna |
| 2000 - Aaron Leeper, Jamestown |
| 2001 - Mike Radon, St. Francis |
| 2002 - Jehuu Caulcrick, Clymer |
| 2003 - Keien Williams, Eden |
| 2004 - James Starks, Niagara Falls |
| 2005 - Naaman Roosevelt, St. Joseph's |
| 2006 - Curtis Underwood, Lackawanna |
| 2007 - Reggie Garner, Cardinal O' Hara |
| 2008 - Deshanaro Morris, Sweet Home |
| 2009 - Zack Sopak, Southwestern |
| 2010 - Joe Licata, Williamsville South |
| 2011 - Chad Kelly, St. Joseph's |
| Akeel Lynch, St. Francis |