| Dave Conklin, Hinsdale - 13.4 yds. (1975) |
| Blair Estarfa, Maryvale - 13 yds (2008) |
| Larry Croft, Forestville - 12.7 yds. (2008) |
| Capone Smith, Lackawanna - 12.6 yds. (2008) |
| Thad Johnson, Frewsburg - 12.4 yds. (2011) |
| Chad Kelly, St. Joseph's - 12.3 yds. (2010) |
| Gary Feagin, Niagara Catholic - 12.2 yds. (1986) |
| Joe West, Lackawanna - 11.7 yds. (1998) |
| John Cerminara, Niagara Catholic - 11.4 yds. (1982) |
| Robert Davis, Cardinal O'Hara - 11.3 yds. (2010) |
| Dave Johnson, Ellicottville - 11.3 yds. (2010) |
| Kevin Chillis, McKinley - 11.1 yds. (2008) |
| Frank Furguiele, Maple Grove - 11.1 yds. (1959) |
| Robert Chapman, Hinsdale - 11.1 yds. (1984) |
| Brandon DeCheine, North Tonawanda - 11 yds. (2001) |
| Ryan Genco, Silver Creek - 10.8 yds (2006) |
| Major Cole, Turner-Carroll - 10.7 yds. (1996) |
| Vinny Bomasuto, Dunkirk - 10.7 yds. (2010) |
| Vince Ferrugia, Cardoinal Mindszenty - 10.7 yds. (1958) |
| Chris Rehbaum, St. Joseph's - 10.6 yds. (1978) |
| Brent Robbins, Randolph - 10.6 yds. (2010) |
| Malik Campbell, Turner-Carroll - 10.1 yds. (1995) |
| Vic Collins, South Park - 10 yds. (1992) |
| Pat Fuller, Silver Creek - 10 yds. (2007) |
| Dave Schmildi, Wilson - 10 yds. (1991) |
| Nick Jackson, Randolph - 10 yds. (2006) |